|
Updated: 1:39 PM Nov 9, 2009
Budget-Cutting Bill Could Help Puppy Mills
Lincoln, Neb. Puppy mills in Nebraska could soon get a break if state senators pass L.B. 6, changing the way the Department of Agriculture inspects cat and dog breeding facilities.
Posted: 12:39 PM Nov 9, 2009Reporter: Christie Bett Email Address: christie.bett@1011now.com |
|
There could soon be less accountability for puppy mills across the state, if a new budget-cutting bill is passed.
It's an industry where abuse of rules many times means abuse of animals. And Legislative Bill 6, introduced by Senator Tom Carlson of Holdrege to save just under $200,000, would limit dog and cat breeding facilities to complaint-only inspections - a method many say is unreliable.
"Is this something we'd like to do? No. But we're kind of acting like surgeons back here because we have to have a balanced budget and we're looking for areas we could change for a temporary period of time," Carlson said.
Carlson proposed the bill last week, which he says would save approximately $182,000 over the next 18 months. But Executive Director of the Captial Humane Society Bob Downey says it will cost much more down the road to fix the inevitable problems to follow.
"Several years ago when additional funding was given to the commercial dog and cat inspection program, a lot of good things happened. Mandatory inspections of facilities at least once every two years that are licensed, so that people with knowledge about what's going on in there can see that things aren't necessarily going well," Downey said.
Senator Tony Fulton of Lincoln has worked in the past to make kennel inspections mandatory, and says a complaint-driven inspection process just won't cut it.
"The bill was well-intentioned and perhaps it's necessary in the end, but I'm going to be working within the budgetary process to ensure that what we did in the last budget is protected, because I've spent three years on this issue and I have some knowledge that there is some need there," Fulton said.
A need Carlson says he doesn't want to ignore, just prioritize.
"We've authorized the expenditure of funds in the first place, hopefully for good reason, but if it comes down to money spent on people or money spent on animals, I'm afraid I'll go with people," Carlson said.
But for those animals, who don't have a voice, Downey stresses the state is still responsible.
"I don't put people not being cared for over animals not being cared for, but society is a balance of caring for everything that is alive and I think we have that responsibility," Downey said.
Since the legislation requiring inspections of the breeding facilities was passed in 2007, Senator Carlson says the number of inspections of breeding facilities has gone up from about 130 a year to 700 to 900 a year, shutting down more than 30 offending operations.
If you want your opinion heard, L.B. 6 is fourth on the agenda for the public hearings at the State Capitol Building to start Monday afternoon at 1:30 p.m.
To hear more from Senator Fulton on what to expect this week in the Legislature, just click on the video links above.
Latest Comments
Leave it up to the federal inspectors. The state should have never gotten into these inspections.
Back to the story... how do we STOP Carlson's bill? Regulations should be tougher, not lessened.
There is a standard to treatment of animals by which certain acts are considered cruelty. People and breeders who violate these standards should be prosecuted. I love my animals (sheep, chickens) and ensure they get fed and cared for. When the time comes I kill them and eat them. First budget cuts are a reality that needs to be faced. Here is an idea which could benefit both the overall cost and also the animal lovers. How about a tiered approach, much like is done with organic foods. For example, a general breeder would be permitted to operate under normal standards with biannual inspection and a certified 'organic/green/good guy' breeder would operate under tighter rules, a fee and greater oversight (such as free space to roam and other, more generous, conditions). In this way the overall cost of oversight on animal breeding would be reduced and at the same time those who care about the treatment of animals could have their organic hot dogs.
Jeff, please go the the Hearts United for Animals website and educate yourself on what really happens to dogs at puppy mills. Fed well? healthy?? Read the stories and see what you think then. That's what happens when these out to make a buck puppy mills aren't regulated. If you can read those stories without getting sick, you truly aren't human. Since when is it natural for dogs to have their teeth rotted out by age 4, or to never be groomed, and to spend their whole lives in crates barely big enough to turn around in, stacked on top of each other, with the stool and urine pouring down on the ones beneath. Many of the dogs rescued from these places have to be put down, as they're far to ill to survive, and that's at young ages. But as long as they can still pump out a litter, that's all that matters. Most of those dogs have never been petted, and are terrified of human contact. Good breeders are wonderful, but puppy mills should never exist.
Jeff, do you really think they are being fed well and are healthy and people really care about them in puppy mills? "Pop out a litter a few times a year." That sounds like a breeze to you, huh? Try doubling that number. You clearly don't know anything about puppy mills if you think those animals are living the good life. It's quite the opposite. They should be banned completely and if not that then restricted to a small number that are heavily monitored. It's just sad what goes on out there and people just don't get it. They don't want to know. They just want a cute little puppy for Christmas or whatever. While older dogs are locked away in cages waiting to die. Yes, dogs and cats aren't people, but I think they'd treat us more humanly if the shoe was on the other foot.
As far as I can see, having some regulation to bring these areas of suffering up to some kind of code is a good thing. The ruthless owners of these places would act a lot differently if they know that someone was watching over their shoulder! It would give someone the chance to go into these places and assure that the animals were treated kindly. Dogs and cats are not people, and if someone wants to treat them humanely I do not understand what the problem really is. Obivously, there is a market for these places, b/c they exist in the first place. I do not agree with some of the practices, but speaking from a dog or cat's point of view, why should I care if I pop out a litter a few times a year? I am being fed well, I am healthy, and someone must care about me b/c I am still here....so...What is the real problem? It is stupid to impose human ideals on animals.
Hope Senator Fulton can help the kennels here. We don't need puppy mills muddying the industry and this has been a long drawn out deal anyway.
I feel nothing but disgust. This CAN NOT go through. Budget cuts that could HELP puppy mills?! HELP. Seriously?! Why should the state be one giant enabler to animal abuse? That's what this piece of leg. would do. These animals need our help. They are prisoners of war. Female animals bread up to 6-7 times/year. They are FORCED to breed. They are in cages 24/7. Never feeling grass, never being pet, never being loved, never getting to be an animal. And what for? a quick buck?! No, in no way is that right. I do understand that there are many concerns and "issues" going on in today's society. But at the same time, we have programs in place for specific demographics. And those programs are being debated on a constant basis. The demographics using programs have the ability to VOICE their opinions and fight for changes. Animals do not. It just blows my mind that a headlines reads, "help puppy mills" is even up for debate.
LESS accountability for puppy mills????? Great idea, guys. {{rolls eyes}}
| Community Calendar
Search and post upcoming community events |
|
| Healthy Everyday - The Hearing Clinic
Health tips and stories |
|
| It's Your Shot
Share your photos |
|
| Buy It Nebraska
Sell your stuff... buy some more! |
|
| Lance's Journal
Nebraska's hidden treasures |
|
| MomsEveryday.com
Advice for all Moms! |


