Seat Belts and School Buses
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 11:05 AM May 5, 2010
Seat Belts and School Buses
When it comes to cars - we know seat belts save lives. But what about seat belts on school buses? The issue has been debated for years - but those for and against the idea continue to disagree.
Posted: 7:24 PM Oct 29, 2009
Reporter: Serese Cole
Email Address: serese.cole@1011now.com
width:200 and height: 150 and picwidth: 200 and pciheight: 150
Font Size:

When it comes to cars - we know seat belts save lives. But what about on school buses?

In August, dozens of Norris students were rushed to area hospitals after their school bus collided with a pick-up truck. While there were no serious injuries, the crash stirred up the debate that's been brewing across the nation for years. Should school buses have seat belts?

Currently there are only four states: New York, New Jersey, Florida and California that require seat belts on school buses weighing more than 10,000 pounds.

Here in Nebraska, the issue has been debated in the legislature three years in a row. Last year, the bill was stalled in committee - but the debate lingers on.

"When you send your children off on a school bus, you expect your kids to come home safe," said Tom Rief.

But that didn't happen.

Seven years ago, a school bus carrying the Seward marching band hit a guardrail and fell more than 60 feet. Brenda and Tom Rief's two sons were on that bus.

14-year-old Tait was severely injured. His brother, Luke, walked away from the crash.

"Luke heard the bus hit the guardrail and he braced, he spread his legs apart between the seats and grabbed the overhead racks and said he basically became his own seat belt and rode the fall out," Brenda said.

"He's fine and we think it's because he was able to hold himself in his seat and wasn't flying around the bus like Tait was," Tom said.

Three students and a parent died as a result of the crash. But transportation officials, like Bill McCoy with Lincoln Public Schools, says the school bus industry is still one of the safest out there.

"A school bus is nine times safer than a passenger vehicle," McCoy said.

The National Highway Traffic Safety administration says out of the 26 million students who ride the bus to school everyday, less than ten are killed in school bus crashes a year. But thousands are injured - up to 475 severely.

There's kids like Tait whose parents say putting seat belts on school buses is common sense.

"We have seat belts; you don't take your baby home from the hospital unless they are in a proper, appropriate car seat - and so why do we send our kids off on their first day of kindergarten in a school bus that they can't be belted into that just seems crazy," said Brenda.

At the heart of the seat belt debate is a concept called compartmentalization. According to federal transportation officials, school buses are now designed to have higher, wider and thicker backs with extra energy absorbing padding and materials. The seats are also closer together providing a cocoon like atmosphere which the government says can protect kids in the event of a crash.

"It looks like it should be safe and it probably is safe on a front end collision or rear-end collision, but from the side or a rollover - the high backseats and the padding on the seats doesn't make much difference when you're flying around a bus," Tom said.

School districts have other concerns - like cost.

"We estimate that for a large school bus it would cost about an additional 7-10 thousand dollars to equip that bus with lap-shoulder belts," said McCoy.

"It's a lot of money but one injury like Tait's he has probably already had 1 to 1.5 million in medical expenses - so there's a cost there also," said Tom. "If that would have been prevented that sure would have paid for a lot of seat belts. "

"The first three years of therapy were real hard," said Tait.

Tait has come along way but his brain injuries are so severe he usually can't remember what happened the day before. His parents say if one life or injury is spared by adding seat belts to school buses - it's worth it.

The government's still waiting to determine if it is. But we could have an answer from the government soon. It's waiting for results of a three year study being done by the University of Alabama that's expected to shed some light on the effectiveness on seat belts on school buses.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Jenna Location: Florida on Jan 27, 2011 at 07:48 PM

seatbelts are very impoprtant its better to be safe than sorry 7 out of 10 accidents in buses are side or rollover accidents and seat belts protect against these yeah its not as likely for a bus to fall off an overpass but it doesnt have to be that way for any other accident to occur and for children to get injured or killed thesse buses that we think are perfectly safe for our children really arent we need seat belts in school buses its for the childrens safety there is no reason a child should be using a seat belt as a weapon unless they are too small to know right from wrong or they are to playful there should be some sort of vigilance in the buses to prevent this from happening but something has to be done.
Posted by: Bob Location: UK on Jan 23, 2011 at 11:13 AM

Hi, I remember having countless problems with my 5 yr old son just to get him to wear his seat belt. If any parents out there are having similar issues like we did with their children i would like to suggest something that we used to help get our son to wear his seat belt. I've included the link below which will take you directly to a children's song we found online. Might be worth giving it a try if all else fails. It worked for us. Kind regards Bob website : http://www.wix.com/speakuptoyourteacher/order-page/buzzy
Posted by: Shaunte Location: Fairbury on Nov 11, 2009 at 08:30 PM

I agree, the law stays buckle up or get a ticket. Just because their a bus, don't mean they don't have to. They can go just as fast as a car, or truck. They also go on long trips. My 8 eight year old told me she don't have to buckle up cause she don't on the bus. What example is the school giving? Plus I have seen more than three in a seat before which is against the law.
Posted by: A Mother Location: Lincoln on Nov 5, 2009 at 02:09 PM

Both of my children ride the bus to school. Though I am grateful that they are able to ride the bus, i do worry about safety. I think that the school should provide seat belts on the buses. There are always 2 adults in each bus to monitor what goes on. Someone could keep an eye on the kids and make sure they wear them.
Posted by: Lisa Location: Lincoln on Nov 4, 2009 at 09:24 AM

Seat belts do save lives, it has been proven in cars, pickups, suvs--but not enough studies have been done to be convincing how they will help in school buses. Proponent for Education-I agree with you about that it is the parents responsibility to teach their kids about seat belt usage. The problem is in this world we live today where it is always someone elses fault--when a kid gets hurt by either not having their belt in an accident on or flinging it around and hitting another kid--many parents are going to be blaming the bus driver for not watching what the kids were doing. I sure wouldn't want to be driving a bus full of say 60 kids (or less for that matter), and make sure they all have their belts on right and watching the road. So, will they hire another adult to ride the route to ensure correct belt usage to take pressure off the driver? I doubt it. I think there are pros and cons both ways.
Posted by: Kimmy Location: Eastern nebraska on Nov 4, 2009 at 08:20 AM

I think Seat belts should be on buses and enforced. I have seen kids standing on the bus hanging hands out window and such and that just distracts the bus driver.They also need to put more camera's on the bus then what they have and that way they can watch who does not put it on.Why do pre school buses have seat belts but the big buses don't make no sence to me. What is the difference then getting in a car and putting on ur seat belts its a law why not on the bus?
Posted by: Proponent for Education Location: Eastern Nebraska on Nov 3, 2009 at 07:13 PM

I am amazed at the many comments from others that point out such negativity and lack of education regarding the use of seat belts and associated safety. How do parents get kids to wear seat belts in personal vehicles? Kids are taught to wear them--no negotiation! The same goes for school buses; parents need to teach their kids to wear seat belts. Seat belts really do save lives and reduce injuries. Educate yourself on the true benefits of seat belts--then you can decide how much your child's life is worth. Sure, a possible broken bone from lack of a seat belt will heal, but a brain injury will not. How about death? Do you really think comparing kids who misbehave and might use the seat belt as a weapon is even comparable to a child's death? The real issue many of you mention is the children using the seat belt correctly. Parents need to take responsibility to ensure whether their kids are in their car, in a friend's car, or on a school bus, their child uses a seat belt!
Posted by: Angie Location: Columbus on Nov 3, 2009 at 07:27 AM

First, a question for those who who think compartmentalization will protect passengers in a tip-over accident: how? Second, even if a child is hysterical and belted in after an accident, they will most likely be conscious and have no severe broken bones, and thus, able to calm down, undo the belt, and walk off the bus. If they are not belted in and are flying around, there's a chance that an injury itself will keep them from being able to walk off the bus. Alot of the arguments against seatbelts are the same ones we heard for years about seatbelts in cars - have we not learned anything from that? I do agree that is will be an issue to get the older children to keep using the seatbelts in the bus, but I think if it starts with little children, it will just become routine like it is with carseats for little ones now.
Posted by: Annabelle Location: Lincoln on Nov 2, 2009 at 09:49 PM

I feel that maybe the kids would freeze if the bus caught on fire dipped in water could they think to undo the seat belts in time. That is what worries me.
Posted by: celest Location: South Central NE on Nov 2, 2009 at 08:25 PM

Can you imagine how many kids might have their teeth knocked out just by using the seat belt like a weapon? Who is going to make sure that the seatbelts are buckled properly?
Posted by: Jim Location: Lincoln on Nov 2, 2009 at 02:02 PM

LPS has many skilled drivers. However, many are not. The posts on my blog include a few of the dozens of LPD accident reports I have. How is a bus 9 times safer with silly accidents like the ones posted. See at: http://schoolbusaccidents.blogspot.com/2009/11/blog-post.html
Posted by: LPS DRIVER Location: Lincoln on Nov 2, 2009 at 01:20 PM

What does this Bill McCoy know? He has NEVER driven a school bus and he makes an embarassment out of the few good drivers we have. The new drivers have accidents every week, hitting parked vehicles is way too common. LPS hires the new drivers if they only have golf cart driving skills. SAD
Posted by: Realistic Location: Lincoln on Nov 1, 2009 at 11:36 PM

I am a proponent of seat belt usage, but feel that placing them in a school bus is unrealistic. Seat belts are only as good as their usage, and who is going to be responsible to make sure they are used and used correctly. The driver may verify the child puts the seat belt on when sitting down, but cannot guarantee that the child keeps it on correctly. Who is going to verify the condition of the seat belts? With the abuse that school age children can inflict on their surroundings the condition would need to be checked every day to insure proper working status. Vehicles like buses do not tend to roll but may tip over, the compartmentalization design works to protect the passengers. Yes the Seward bus tipped and went off bridge, but it is impossible to say that seat belts would have made a difference. Falling off a 60 foot bridge involves immense traumatic force, and no safety design works for every possible accident scenario. Parents always have the option of driving their child
Posted by: Phyllis Location: Nebraska on Nov 1, 2009 at 10:14 PM

I was a bus driver for several years. Always wondered why seat belts weren't required. The kids would be safer and the driver could concentrate more on driving than trying to monitor the kids.
Posted by: Braydon Finecy Location: Hall County on Nov 1, 2009 at 10:12 PM

I think that the seat belts in school buses won't help as much as you think. One problem is that you have to get the students to wear them which won't be that easy. Also the cost for the seat belts, how often do school buses even crash anyway, who's going to pay that price tag anyway. Cause I can say to put seat belts on school buses too if I'm not the one paying for them.